On Thursday, Nov. 5, Maria Flores Garcia, UMD freshman studying public health science, and her mother Mirna were detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) while at a routine check-in with immigration services in Baltimore. Since then, the university community has outcried the detention, and Murray Osorio, the law firm representing the two, has released information about the case.
Maria and her mother entered the U.S. from El Salvador in December 2016, when the two were apprehended by Customs and Border Protection in the Rio Grande Valley of Texas. The two were released into the U.S. and placed under removal proceedings under the Obama administration. Maria was 9.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said earlier this week that Maria and her mother were issued a final order of removal in February 2021. But that same year and possibly in the same court order, the mother and daughter were granted a Convention Against Torture (CAT) protection, according to Murray Osorio.
Granting both CAT protection and a final order of removal together is standard procedure — first, a judge says that the individuals are deportable, and then the judge issues a CAT protection to block that removal. After being granted the CAT protection, the two were likely released under an “order of supervision,” where they could live, work, and attend school in the U.S. but had to check in with ICE regularly.
The CAT protection, which prevents someone from being sent back to a country where they face high risk of torture, makes it strictly illegal for the DHS to deport Maria and her mother to El Salvador.
For many years, having CAT protection meant that you’d likely continue to live in the U.S. and didn’t face an imminent risk of deportation.
But in February 2025, under the Trump administration, a new rule emerged — third country deportation. The policy states that people who are under CAT protection are now able to be deported to a third country — not their home country, and not even required to be a country that they are familiar with. More than 300 people under CAT protection have been deported to countries where they have no ties under the Trump administration, according to Human Rights Watch.
That’s why the DHS isn’t saying they’ll deport the two to El Salvador — instead, according to Murray Osorio, the DHS wants to deport them to Mexico, a country where neither of the women have legal status.
Mexico regularly buses Salvadorans deported from the United States back to El Salvador, even people who were protected by CAT in the U.S.
“The judge’s order says ICE can’t send Maria and Mirna to El Salvador,” Maria and her mother’s attorney, Justice Haynes, said in a Wednesday night press release. “So ICE wants to send them to a country that will.”
This story has been updated.
Image credits: Cover image from Cesar Saavedra’s GoFundMe.


Leave a Reply